Apparel Mystery Bag

(49 reviews) Write a Review
Frequently bought together:


They're Back! Our Unbelievably popular Mystery Bags are back again! Get one while you can! Mystery Bags each contain at least $40 worth of apparel; skirts, tops, dresses, jackets, etc. We always sell out within days of making these available so don't miss your chance to be surprised!

Size selections change with what we have available. If you do not see your size listed, check back often, as availability changes frequently!

Please note; mystery bags are prepacked. There may or may not be overlap with a previously purchased bag. If you buy more than one -in the same order- we'll make them different. We can not honor requests like "don't send me any skirts" or "don't send me anything blue". It's a mystery!

No returns or exchanges


View AllClose

49 Reviews

  • 5
    Thanks for helping me branch out!

    Posted by Tawny Wagner on May 3rd 2020

    I was very pleased with the mystery bag. I got something that I wouldn’t normally purchase, but I loved it and I’m excited to wear something new and a little outside of my comfort zone.

  • 3
    A little disappointing

    Posted by Angel on Apr 6th 2020

    This is my first goody bag. I only got one item, but it's nice and certainly would sell for $40 at least. It was a cap sleeve high low shirt(??) with a single button. I liked the dark green color and it fits fine, but it's not really my style. I might try again, because it sounds like other people got stuff I would like, I just wasn't very lucky this time.

  • 3
    A hit and a miss

    Posted by Kim on Jan 12th 2020

    First time ordering and just gotten it today. The hit was the top. Liked it from the moment I pulled it out of the bag. Fits well and plan to wear it soon. The miss was the leggings. Not a fan of the pattern. But they might end up as pajama bottoms.

  • 5
    Mystery bag

    Posted by Teresa cheeseman on Dec 9th 2019

    I bought this for my daughter for her birthday. She just had brain surgery. So she has no hair. I was really worried because she is not very girly and there was a dress in the bag. It was a very nice black dress with pockets. She loved it. She wore it on her first day back to high school. It gave her so much confidence. Thank you

  • 5

    Posted by Jillian Zaorski on Sep 28th 2019

    I admit I was a bit nervous when I peeked inside because the kind of skull print I saw is not the kind I would usually pick for myself but I have no problem stepping out of my comfort zone. To my pleasant surprise it was a maxi dress. The cut and style of the dress is very me and it looks amazing on so I love it. It is a bit too long but I don't think it's anything my heels won't fix. Super happy with my purchase. Debating whether I will order this one again or step up to the double dip, Eying that footwear mystery bag too now LOL. I even loved the purple bag LOL.

  • 3
    Appeal mystery bag.

    Posted by Autumn Lawhun on May 9th 2018

    This is the first time I got the appeal bag. I got two items. A plan black T shirt with spikes on the pocket. This shirt is okay. It might look cute with some skirts. My second item I'm not even sure if it's supposed to be a dress or shirt. I order a small. This item says it's a small but it's huge! Huge as a dress and shirt. If it wasn't so baggy I would love it. My items got here in 3 days! I may try this again.

  • 5
    I absolutely love this

    Posted by Sierra Tiller on Mar 23rd 2018

    I received my muster bag yesterday and it is so worth it! I was worried because I'm a plus size girl and a lot of times it's hard to find cute, alternative clothes in my size. I got two items, a dress and a pair of black leggings. The dress has a shear red top and sleeves, with the body of the dress looks like an underbust corset. It's short, which is something I'm not use too, but the leggings make it perfect! I have to wear a plain cami under it, but it's beautiful! They seem to take your previous orders into consideration, because it perfectly makes the creepers i bought. I just ordered the double dipped bundle and footwear mystery bags, and can't wait to see what I get next!

  • 5

    Posted by Dena on Feb 19th 2018

    So I ordered this bag and the accessory one a while back. I got a beautiful shirt with flowy sleeves and a jacket that I like to call my Black Widow jacket. They both fit my style, and I will definitely be ordering from here again.

  • 3

    Posted by heather on Nov 4th 2017

    after buying a few sale items (all of which fit well and i wear frequently), i decided to try to the Mystery Bag to see what i'd get. i ordered a Small, even though i fluctuate between XS and M. i read others' reviews, and most of them were positive. my Mystery Bag arrived yesterday, and was surprised to receive only one item - the Black Crinoline Days dress - while others had received multiple items. it's a gorgeous dress and it fit well; however, it's strapless and as someone with back issues i can only wear dresses with straps/sleeves for support reasons. but it will make a great gift for family/friends this season, so it won't go to waste!

View AllClose